| Platinum | Domenick & Pia Downtown Pizzeria |
| Gold | Park Pizza |
| Silver | Domenic's and Vinnie's Pizza |
| Bronze | Dimitri's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Giovanni's Restaurante |
| Top Pick | Louie's Pizza House |
| Top Pick | Mario's Pizza & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Martino's Pizzaria |
| Top Pick | Pepe's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Ro's Pizza Restaurant |