| Platinum | Browns Irish Pub |
| Gold | Sun Kee Kitchen |
| Silver | Signatures Restaurant |
| Bronze | Domenick & Pia Downtown Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | AMALFI RESTAURANT & PIZZA |
| Top Pick | Angelina's Pizza |
| Top Pick | East Gate Luncheonette |
| Top Pick | Mario's Pizza & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Tiramisu Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Via Al Paraiso |