| Platinum | Wing It On! |
| Gold | Charleys Cheesesteaks |
| Silver | Frankie's Hot Dogs |
| Silver | Johnny B, S |
| Bronze | Verdi |
| Top Pick | Gayle's Depot Square Farm Shoppe |
| Top Pick | Jesse Camille's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | San Marino Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Signatures Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Whooster Pizza & Restaurant |